Heiniu, Animal Services and What Happens Next
On September 20, 2026, Heiniu’s owner, writing as an East Gwillimbury property taxpayer, sent the same four questions individually to Mayor Virginia Hackson and each sitting Ward Councillor.
Substantive-response deadline: September 25, 2026 — 7:00 p.m. Eastern Time.
The original request stated that this round of the public record would close at that time and would reflect the responses actually received by the deadline.
Roster note: East Gwillimbury Council is normally composed of the Mayor and six Ward Councillors. The second Ward 3 seat, formerly held by Susan Lahey, was declared vacant on September 9, 2026 following her resignation, and the Town stated that it would remain vacant for the remainder of the 2022–2026 term. The September 20 request was therefore sent to the Mayor and the five sitting Ward Councillors. Official Town source.
Optional supplemental response window: After contract materials relating to the Canine Foundations engagement were added to the public record, each original recipient was given the same optional opportunity to provide a supplemental written response. The supplemental window closed at 7:00 p.m. Eastern Time on September 30, 2026.
No response was required. Any supplemental response would be recorded separately and would not alter the historical response status as of the September 25 deadline.
Original Request
September 20, 2026
Subject: Questions to East Gwillimbury Council — Heiniu, Animal Services and What Happens Next
The public copy below shows the version sent to the Mayor. The same substantive text was sent individually to each listed sitting Councillor, with the salutation changed for the recipient.
Read complete original request
From: Yang Yu · Sent individually to Mayor Hackson and each sitting Ward Councillor
Mayor Hackson,
I am Heiniu’s owner and an East Gwillimbury property taxpayer.
I am sending the same four questions to the Mayor and every current member of East Gwillimbury Council. I am asking each of you to respond individually and in writing.
This email, your response, and the response status will be published on Heiniu.ca and may also be shared publicly, including on social media.
This is separate from my standing Four Public Questions for current office holders and registered candidates. Those questions remain open. Responses to this email will be kept as a separate public record.
On May 4, 2026, Heiniu died during an Animal Services response in East Gwillimbury.
The Canine Foundations report was released on September 15. East Gwillimbury has said that Town staff will review the report and follow up on Aurora’s Animal Services action plan.
These events occurred during the current Council term, and that term has not yet ended.
I am not asking for another general statement from the Town.
I am asking about your own record as an elected member.
1. What did you personally do after May 4?
Since May 4, what did you personally do about Heiniu’s death and the Animal Services response?
For example, did you ask for a briefing, ask questions of East Gwillimbury staff or Aurora, request records, look into the Animal Services arrangement, raise concerns about oversight, or ask for Council to discuss the matter?
Please tell me:
What did you do, and when did you do it?
If there is a public record, please provide the date or link.
If you took no action, please simply say so.
If some of your actions involved confidential or closed-session matters, please only describe what you are legally allowed to disclose.
2. What responsibility does East Gwillimbury have for Animal Services provided by Aurora?
Aurora provides Animal Services to East Gwillimbury.
East Gwillimbury also authorizes Animal Services officers to enforce East Gwillimbury’s own Animal Care and Control By-law.
So my question is simple:
Do you believe East Gwillimbury still has responsibility for overseeing the quality, safety and accountability of the Animal Services provided to its residents?
Please answer:
Yes / No / Unable to assess
If Yes, please briefly explain what you believe East Gwillimbury should be responsible for overseeing, including matters such as service quality, training, supervision, emergency response, animal welfare, serious incidents, and whether the service being provided meets East Gwillimbury’s expectations.
Please also answer:
What, if anything, changed in East Gwillimbury’s oversight after May 4?
If your answer is No, please explain why.
If you are Unable to assess, please explain what information you would need.
3. After the report was released, do you believe the three most important questions have been answered?
Please answer each one:
Yes / No / Unable to assess
A. Do we now have a clear answer about why Heiniu died?
B. Do we now have a clear answer about whether the way Heiniu was handled and restrained on May 4 followed the applicable training, policies and procedures?
C. Do we now have a clear answer about who should be held responsible for what happened on May 4?
For each answer, please briefly explain what information or evidence you are relying on.
If you answer No or Unable to assess to any of these questions:
What do you believe still needs to happen to get a clear answer?
If you believe nothing further needs to happen, please say so and explain why.
4. What will you personally do before your current term ends?
East Gwillimbury has said that Town staff will review the Canine Foundations report and follow up on Aurora’s Animal Services action plan.
Before your current term ends, are you prepared to support or take any further action relating to East Gwillimbury’s oversight of Animal Services; the current Animal Services arrangement with Aurora; making sure promised reforms are actually carried out; questions that are still unanswered; correcting or clarifying any public statement that you believe is not supported by the evidence; making public any records that can legally be released; providing a formal written response to Heiniu’s family; or leaving the next Council a clear written record of what is still unresolved?
Please answer one final question clearly:
What, specifically, are you prepared to do before your current term ends, and by when?
If you do not intend to take any further action, please say that clearly as well.
Response requested
Please answer the four numbered questions directly.
General statements of concern, sympathy or support are not a substitute for answering the questions.
For accuracy and public record purposes, please provide your response in writing.
Whether or not you return to office next term, the questions are the same:
What did you do?
Where do you stand now?
What will you do before your current term ends?
Please confirm receipt no later than September 22, 2026.
Please provide your substantive written response no later than 7:00 p.m. Eastern Time on September 25, 2026.
You may reply directly to this email or provide a link to a written public response.
Publication and public record
This email, substantive responses, and dated response statuses will be kept in a long-term public archive on Heiniu.ca and may also be shared publicly, including on social media.
Please prepare your response on the understanding that its substantive contents may be published.
I intend to publish substantive responses in full, as received, subject to necessary privacy, confidentiality, legal and safety safeguards.
Please do not include private, confidential, legally privileged or third-party information that you are not authorized to make public.
Publishing a response does not mean that I agree with it or independently verify it.
The public record will distinguish between a substantive response, an acknowledgement or administrative reply, and no response.
If a numbered question is not answered, that will be recorded as a fact without assigning a motive.
If you answer “Unable to assess” or “Cannot comment,” that will be recorded in those terms.
If no reply of any kind is received by the substantive-response deadline, the public record will state:
“No response received by the deadline.”
If only an acknowledgement or administrative reply is received by the deadline, that status will be recorded accurately.
The public record for this request will close at 7:00 p.m. Eastern Time on September 25, 2026, and will reflect the responses actually received by that deadline. Responses received after that deadline will not be included in this round of the public record.
Thank you,
Yang Yu
Heiniu’s owner
East Gwillimbury Property Taxpayer
Heiniu.ca
East Gwillimbury Council
Mayor Virginia Hackson
Acknowledgement / administrative reply only. No substantive response received by the deadline.
On September 25, Gina Casey, Executive Coordinator to Mayor & Council, acknowledged the request on Mayor Hackson’s behalf and stated that Mayor Hackson was away with limited access to email and was therefore unable to respond as requested. A further follow-up was sent the same day. No substantive response from Mayor Hackson was received by the 7:00 p.m. deadline.
Correspondence Record
September 20, 2026 — Original request sent
September 25, 2026 — Follow-up sent
From: Yang Yu · To: Mayor Virginia Hackson
Mayor Hackson,
I’m following up on my email below regarding Heiniu, Animal Services and what happens next. The response deadline provided in that email is today, September 25, at 7:00 p.m. Eastern Time.
I have not yet received confirmation that the email was received. Please confirm receipt. If you intend to provide a substantive written response to the questions, please send it by the deadline so that I can accurately reflect it in the public record.
Thank you,
Yang Yu
September 25, 2026 — Administrative reply received
From: Gina Casey, Executive Coordinator to Mayor & Council · On behalf of Mayor Hackson
Good morning,
I am acknowledging receipt of your email below on behalf of Mayor Hackson and share that Mayor Hackson is currently away with limited access to email and therefore unable to respond to your email as requested.
Thank you,
Gina Casey
Executive Coordinator to Mayor & Council
Town of East Gwillimbury
September 25, 2026 — Further follow-up sent
From: Yang Yu · To: Gina Casey / Mayor’s Office
Good morning Gina,
Thank you for confirming receipt.
I would appreciate a clear answer on one point: does Mayor Hackson intend to provide a substantive written response to my questions before the end of her term, or does she not intend to respond?
I understand that she is currently away and has limited access to email. However, these questions were directed to her in her capacity as Mayor. They concern an incident that occurred in East Gwillimbury and Animal Services provided to East Gwillimbury residents under the Town’s contract with the Town of Aurora.
Beyond general Town statements, I have not seen Mayor Hackson provide a substantive response addressing accountability, what East Gwillimbury intends to do for its own residents, or what concrete action she personally has taken on this matter. If I have missed such action, please identify the specific public record.
I am also very disappointed with how my FOI request has been handled. On May 7, 2026, I submitted an FOI request to the Town of East Gwillimbury concerning Heiniu / CAS-61344-V5K8Z8. On May 15, the Town directed me to the Town of Aurora and advised that East Gwillimbury would work with Aurora regarding responsive records that might be located. By July 17, my lawyer had formally advised the Town that the continuing delay could amount to a deemed refusal and requested the responsive records. On September 2, the Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario opened IPC File MA26-01167 and asked East Gwillimbury to confirm whether a final decision had been issued. As of today, I have not received a final decision from East Gwillimbury or the complete records I requested.
If the Town believes any part of that timeline is inaccurate, please identify the specific date and document that corrects it.
I am also deeply concerned about how public participation and discussion of this matter have been handled. On September 15, the Town of East Gwillimbury posted “Update on Animal Services Incident” on its official Facebook page, but comments on that post were disabled. The Town was therefore able to publish its position on this matter while residents were unable to respond, ask questions, or express their views on that same official post.
I am also concerned about the practical limits on raising this matter at the Council level, including the additional deputation restrictions in place during the 2026 election year. The final Council meeting of the 2022–2026 term has already taken place, and there are no further Council meetings scheduled for the remainder of this term. From the public record available to me, I have not seen this matter receive the level of substantive Council discussion or concrete action that an incident of this seriousness warrants.
If I am missing something, please identify the specific meeting, motion, Council direction, decision, or other concrete action taken.
Mayor Hackson’s term is now coming to an end. So my questions are very direct:
Before she leaves office, does she intend to provide East Gwillimbury residents with a substantive written response on this matter?
Does she intend to take any further substantive action before the end of her term?
If the answer is yes, please confirm what she intends to do. If the answer is no, please confirm that as well.
The full correspondence and responses will be maintained as part of the public record on Heiniu.ca, and I want that record to be complete, clear, and accurate.
Thank you,
Yang
Status at 7:00 p.m., September 25, 2026: Receipt had been acknowledged administratively. No substantive response from Mayor Hackson had been received.
Supplemental response status — September 30, 2026, 7:00 p.m. ET: No supplemental response received.
Ward 1
Councillor Loralea Carruthers
Substantive response received.
Record Summary
Councillor Carruthers responded on September 22. She stated that potential litigation limited what she could say. She described asking for staff briefings, raising concerns, reviewing East Gwillimbury’s contract with Aurora and reading the Canine Foundations report.
She wrote that she had questions about whether Aurora had provided the level of service East Gwillimbury contracted for and that, if Aurora could not demonstrate that it had done so, she believed the contract should be terminated. She also stated that she had asked staff to prepare a report for the incoming Council, including options involving another service-provider model, and that she intended to continue ensuring that the report moved forward.
Her response was provided in narrative form rather than as separate direct answers to every numbered question.
Correspondence Record
September 20, 2026 — Original request sent
September 22, 2026 — Substantive response received
From: Councillor Loralea Carruthers
Hello Mr. Yu,
Thanks for reaching out. Let me start by saying that I am so deeply sorry for what your family has gone through. It makes me heart-sick to hear about what you have endured. You have my condolences.
As this matter is subject to potential litigation, we have been cautioned on what we say so I unfortunately need to keep my comments brief and focused on how we improve so this never happens again.
I can tell you that at every step of the way I have asked for briefings from staff, raising concerns, asking what we could do and what we could say, in order to give you the justice you are seeking, and to explore our options to strengthen animal services in EG, with or without Aurora. I have said repeatedly and publicly that our residents deserve an animal control service they can trust. The communication from Aurora on this has been far below my expectations, to say the least, given they are our service provider.
I have reviewed the contract we have with Aurora and have read the Canine Foundations report and have questions about whether they have provided the level of service that we have contracted them for. This contract will need to be reviewed and if they cannot show that they have been providing what we have contracted, I believe the contract should be terminated. This would have to be a decision by the incoming Council.
I've also asked staff to prepare a report for the incoming Council on both what happened and what happens next, including options to move to another service provider model. I have confidence in our staff that they will put a full report on the table at the earliest opportunity for the incoming Council. It's unfortunate that the Aurora report was released after our last meeting of the term or we could have dealt with it sooner.
As for the remaining term, Council's power is through motions passed in a council meeting and our last one was at the beginning of September, before the report was released to us. With the majority of Council not seeking re-election, this really needs to be dealt with by the incoming Council so they can be held accountable for the decisions made. I can tell you that I will do everything I can to continue to make sure the staff report on this is moving forward so that it is ready when the new Council is sworn in.
I have avoided posting about this on Facebook because some posts I have read come across as campaigning on a tragedy and I don't want you to ever feel that from me. I did post a short post after reading the report because I felt my residents deserved to know that I have been taking this seriously, am deeply disturbed by it and am prepared to act on it. My disappointment on the timing of the release of the Canine Foundations report by Aurora cannot be understated.
Yang, I have done my best to answer all the questions that I can. I hope you will see that I have been working to do all that I can in my role as Councillor and it is my hope that you will see the actions you seek in the next few months. I am so sorry it has taken this long.
Please don't hesitate to call if you need more information.
Loralea
Loralea Carruthers
Ward One Councillor
Town of East Gwillimbury
Supplemental response status — September 30, 2026, 7:00 p.m. ET: No supplemental response received.
Ward 1
Councillor Terry Foster
Substantive response received; numbered questions were not answered individually.
Record Summary
Councillor Foster expressed condolences, referred to Town statements dated September 4 and September 15, and stated that potential litigation limited his response. He also stated that staff would prepare a full report for the incoming Council after the election. The four numbered questions were not answered individually.
Correspondence Record
September 20, 2026 — Original request sent
September 24, 2026 — Response received
From: Councillor Terry Foster
Please accept my condolences to you and your family on the loss of an important member of your family.
The May 4th report was a long time coming and leaves questions to be answered.
I would ask that you refer to the statements from the town dated September 4 and 15.
The fact that this matter is subject to potential litigation I will limit my response.
As I'm certain there are still questions and more to come, staff will be preparing a full report for the incoming council after the election.
TF
Supplemental response status — September 30, 2026, 7:00 p.m. ET: No supplemental response received.
Ward 2
Councillor Brian Johns
Substantive response received.
Record Summary
Councillor Johns responded on September 25 and organized his response around the four questions. He described actions he said he took beginning on May 4, including publicly calling for a report, a review of Animal Services protocols and a review of East Gwillimbury’s service agreement with Aurora.
On East Gwillimbury’s responsibility, he stated that, in his view, East Gwillimbury is responsible for overseeing the Animal Services its residents receive under the arrangement.
On the three questions identified in Question 3, he answered: Why Heiniu died — Partly; whether handling and restraint followed training, policies and procedures — Partly; who should be held responsible — No.
He also stated that on September 24 he had written to the Town’s Chief Administrative Officer, copying Council, seeking a public update on the Town’s follow-up. He committed to write again by October 9 with any information made public in response, or to advise if none had been made public.
Correspondence Record
September 20, 2026 — Original request sent
September 20, 2026 — Receipt acknowledged
From: Councillor Brian Johns
Confirmed receipt.
Let me follow up.
Brian
September 25, 2026 — Follow-up sent
From: Yang Yu · To: Councillor Johns
Councillor Johns,
Thank you for confirming receipt of my email. I’m following up because I have not yet received your substantive written response.
The response deadline provided in the original email is today, September 25, at 7:00 p.m. Eastern Time. If you intend to respond to the questions, please send your response by the deadline so that I can accurately reflect it in the public record.
Thank you,
Yang Yu
September 25, 2026 — Interim reply received
From: Councillor Brian Johns
Thanks. I will get to you today.
September 25, 2026 — Substantive response received
From: Councillor Brian Johns
Hi Mr Yu,
Thank you for your questions. My answers are below.
1. What I did after May 4
On the evening of May 4, I publicly called for three things: a full public report from Aurora Animal Services to East Gwillimbury residents; a review of its protocols for responding to distressed animals, including restraint equipment; and a formal review of East Gwillimbury's service agreement with Aurora.
On the morning of May 5, I attended the protest outside Aurora's municipal offices.
On September 16, I issued a public statement responding to the report, including steps I would bring to Council if elected.
2. East Gwillimbury's responsibility
Yes. In my view, East Gwillimbury is responsible for overseeing the Animal Services its residents receive under this arrangement, even though Aurora delivers them. That means setting clear expectations and checking whether they are met, including for service quality, training, supervision, emergency response, animal welfare and the reporting of serious incidents.
On what has changed: I can't point to any change in East Gwillimbury's oversight that has been made public. The public steps so far are two statements from September 15. The Town said its staff will review the report and follow up on Aurora's action plan. Aurora said it will develop that plan with its municipal partners and present it to the next term of Council in the new year.
3. Have the three questions been answered?
A. Why Heiniu died: Partly.
I'll say this plainly. In my view, Heiniu died because of what happened to him during that Animal Services response. He was alive when officers arrived, and he died while under their control. The report records that visible bleeding developed while he was held with two catch poles.
What the report could not establish is the medical detail. Your counsel's September 17 statement says the necropsy was given to the province's Animal Welfare Services on June 24. That assessment is where the medical answer should come from.
B. Whether handling and restraint followed training, policies and procedures: Partly.
The report's Finding 16 says the officers had been trained and that "key safety elements of that training were not applied during portions of the incident." Finding 15 identifies gaps in the written procedures supporting that training. These are substantive findings. The report also records unresolved factual discrepancies, and it does not establish that particular techniques caused Heiniu's death. Aurora has said it does not agree with every assessment in the report. It should identify which findings it disputes and explain why.
C. Who should be held responsible: No.
The report's findings concern operational decisions, supervision, staffing and procedures. On their own, they do not settle individual disciplinary or legal responsibility. What still needs to happen: Aurora, as the service provider, should respond to those findings through its action plan, and East Gwillimbury should assess whether that response is adequate for its residents.
4. What I will do before my term ends
On September 24, I wrote to the Town's Chief Administrative Officer, copying Council, asking for an update that can be shared publicly on the Town's September 15 follow-up. I asked:
- What work is complete, and what is still under way?
- Has anything changed yet in the service provided in East Gwillimbury?
- Has Aurora provided, or committed to provide, a written implementation plan setting out who is responsible and the timelines?
- When will Council and residents next be updated?
By October 9, I will write to you with any information made public in response, or tell you if none has been.
I am sorry for your family's loss.
Brian Johns
Future correspondence: Councillor Johns stated that he would write by October 9 with any information made public in response to his September 24 follow-up, or advise if none had been made public. Any later email will be added with its actual date and will not alter the September 25 deadline status.
Supplemental response status — September 30, 2026, 7:00 p.m. ET: No supplemental response received.
Ward 2
Councillor Tara Roy-DiClemente
Substantive response received; several numbered questions were not directly answered.
Record Summary
Councillor Roy-DiClemente responded on September 25 and provided a screenshot of a public statement she had made shortly after the incident in May.
She stated that she had been advised the matter would be the subject of an investigation, the results of which she understood to have been released by Aurora on September 15. She stated that the report was released after the last scheduled Council meeting of the term and that, as she understood it, Town staff were reviewing the report and would make recommendations to the newly elected Council.
She also stated that an individual Councillor does not have legislative authority to direct staff and that Council as an elected body must vote to provide direction. Citing the likelihood of legal action, she stated that she did not think it prudent to comment further.
Her response did not provide separate direct answers to each of the four numbered questions.
Correspondence Record
September 20, 2026 — Original request sent
September 25, 2026 — Follow-up sent
From: Yang Yu · To: Councillor Roy-DiClemente
Councillor Roy-DiClemente,
I’m following up on my email below regarding Heiniu, Animal Services and what happens next. The response deadline provided in that email is today, September 25, at 7:00 p.m. Eastern Time.
I have not yet received confirmation that the email was received. Please confirm receipt. If you intend to provide a substantive written response to the questions, please send it by the deadline so that I can accurately reflect it in the public record.
Thank you,
Yang Yu
September 25, 2026 — Substantive response received
From: Councillor Tara Roy-DiClemente
Hello Yang Yu,
I have received your email requesting further information regarding the truly unfortunate situation regarding your dog Heinu. I extend my condolences to you on the loss of your pet.
You asked what I have personally done to address the situation. I attach a screenshot of the statement I made shortly after the incident took place in May.
I was advised that the matter would be the subject of an investigation, the results of which were released by the Town of Aurora on September 15th. This was after the last scheduled Council meeting of the term. As I understand it, Town staff are reviewing the report and will make recommendations to the newly elected Council regarding many of the questions you have.
As an individual member of Council, I do not have the legislative authority to give staff direction. Council as an elected body must vote to give direction.
Given that this matter is likely to be the subject of legal action, I do not think it prudent to comment further.
Sincerely,
Tara
Tara Roy-DiClemente
Councillor, Ward 2
Town of East Gwillimbury
Attachment — May 8 public statement (text transcription)
Attachment supplied with Councillor Roy-DiClemente’s September 25 email
Tara Roy-DiClemente — public statement shown in the screenshot attached to her September 25 email, dated May 8:
I am saddened by this truly unfortunate incident. It is a tragic outcome, and while the online reports are deeply, deeply concerning, I am waiting for the outcome of the investigation before calling for any specific actions to be taken. The Town of Aurora is our contracted service provider, and they obviously have a duty to provide a fulsome report on the situation to us. In the meantime, I extend my condolences to the family who have lost their companion.
Public-copy treatment: the original screenshot is retained with the source email. This page reproduces the visible statement text rather than republishing the social-media interface, profile image, reaction counts or other non-substantive visual material.
Supplemental response status — September 30, 2026, 7:00 p.m. ET: No supplemental response received.
Ward 3
Councillor Scott Crone
Substantive response received.
Record Summary
Councillor Crone responded on September 25. He stated that potential litigation limited the detail of his comments. He described seeking updates and briefings from staff, raising concerns, reviewing East Gwillimbury’s contract with Aurora and reviewing the Canine Foundations report.
He stated that he had requested a staff report for the incoming Council and had discussed Animal Services arrangements with neighbouring municipalities. He wrote that the report had shaken his confidence in Aurora Animal Services’ ability to provide the standard of care he believed East Gwillimbury residents and their pets should receive, and stated that he did not believe the status quo was acceptable.
He stated that he intended to continue pushing for the staff report to be ready when the new Council was sworn in. His response was primarily narrative rather than a separate answer to every numbered question and sub-question.
Correspondence Record
September 20, 2026 — Original request sent
September 25, 2026 — Follow-up sent
From: Yang Yu · To: Councillor Crone
Councillor Crone,
I’m following up on my email below regarding Heiniu, Animal Services and what happens next. The response deadline provided in that email is today, September 25, at 7:00 p.m. Eastern Time.
I have not yet received confirmation that the email was received. Please confirm receipt. If you intend to provide a substantive written response to the questions, please send it by the deadline so that I can accurately reflect it in the public record.
Thank you,
Yang Yu
September 25, 2026 — Substantive response received
From: Councillor Scott Crone
Yang,
Thank you for reaching out. I want to start by saying how truly sorry I am for what your family has been through. Reading about it has genuinely weighed on me, and you have my sincere condolences. I should have gotten this to you sooner, my apologies.
Because this matter could end up in litigation, I've been advised to be careful and keep my remarks focused on next steps rather than details. I hope you'll understand the constraint. But as a dog owner myself, who has shed more tears for the passing of a family pet than I have for humans, I hope you feel that I am an ally to your cause.
What I can tell you is that at every stage I've pushed staff for updates and briefings, raised concerns, and asked what more we could do, both to help you get the accountability you're looking for, and to look at how we strengthen animal control in East Gwillimbury going forward. I've said publicly, more than once, that residents deserve an animal control service they can actually trust. Aurora's communication throughout this has fallen well short of what I'd expect from a contracted service provider.
I've gone through our contract with Aurora and read the Canine Foundations report, and I have real questions about whether they've delivered the level of service we're paying for. That contract needs a full review, and if it turns out they haven't held up their end, I believe that will be grounds for termination, though that decision will fall to the incoming Council.
I've also requested staff to prepare a report for the new Council covering both what happened and what comes next, including alternatives to the current service model. I trust staff to bring that forward as soon as it's ready. It's frustrating that the Aurora report only came out after our final Council meeting of the term; otherwise, we could have acted on this sooner.
As well, I have discussed animal services with neighbouring municipalities. I have spoken with staff about the productive conversation I’ve had with several neighbouring Mayors regarding their own animal control arrangements and their openness to exploring shared or alternative service models with East Gwillimbury. I found the conversations encouraging and believe that real workable options exist for us.
On timing: Council can only act through motions passed at an actual meeting, and our last one was in early September, before this report reached us. Since most of the current Council isn't running again, I genuinely believe this needs to be deliberated by the incoming Council, they're the ones who'll be accountable for whatever comes next. It may be prudent for you to ask all the council candidates what their thoughts are on this issue. That said, I'm going to keep pushing to make sure the staff report is ready the moment the new Council is sworn in.
I've stayed off Facebook on this deliberately. Some of what I've seen posted felt like it was using a tragedy for political points, and I never want you to feel that from me. I’ve gone to great lengths to be respectful to you, your family, and the memory of Heiniu. I did put up a short post after reading the report, because I felt residents deserved to know I was taking it seriously, that it disturbed me, and that I intend to act. I can't overstate how disappointed I am in Aurora's timing in releasing that report.
This report has, regrettably, shaken my confidence in Aurora Animal Services ability to deliver the standard of care that East Gwillimbury residents and their pets deserve. I do not believe the status quo is acceptable. I cannot express enough how disappointed I am with the lack of communication our town has received as a client of Aurora Animal Services.
I know this doesn't answer everything, Yang, but I've tried to be as forthcoming as I can within these constraints. I hope it's clear I've been working hard on this in my role as Councillor, and that you'll see real movement early when Council resumes. I'm sorry this is taking so long. And none of what we do will bring Heiniu back, but hopefully we can prevent future tragedies by the actions we take going forward.
Respectfully,
Scott
Scott Crone
Councillor — Ward 3
Town of East Gwillimbury
Supplemental response status — September 30, 2026, 7:00 p.m. ET: No supplemental response received.
Round closure: The September 20 request established the historical substantive-response deadline of 7:00 p.m. Eastern Time on September 25. A separate optional supplemental response window later closed at 7:00 p.m. Eastern Time on September 30. No supplemental response was required, and the supplemental window does not alter the historical September 25 response status.
A designation of Substantive response received means that a respondent addressed the subject matter beyond a simple acknowledgement or administrative message. It does not mean that every numbered question or sub-question was answered.
Where questions were not directly answered, that fact is identified without assigning a motive. Short summaries are navigation aids only. The complete correspondence is the primary record.
Corrections. Requests to correct factual errors may be sent to heiniuofficial@gmail.com. Verified corrections will be dated and noted transparently without rewriting the historical status recorded at the deadline.
← Back to Council Responses & Correspondence